Results tagged “broadband map”

July 13, 2009 9:25 PM

Broadband Mapping NOFA: "NOFA" Enough, But Not "BADFA" A First Try

After reading the NTIA Broadband Mapping Notice of Funding Availability ("NOFA"), it's clear that the "treasure map" I was hoping for isn't going to materialize.  However, I'm not destroyed, because--relative to my expectations, the NTIA--with one really weird exception, and another, more minor, nit--didn't do so bad at all, especially for having a limited amount of time and no confirmed leader until less than a week prior to the NOFA being released.

OK, to get us all on the same page, Congress told the NTIA to come up with a broadband inventory map when it passed the American Reinvestment and Recovery Act ("Recovery Act") earlier this year.  Prior to passage of the Recovery Act, though, Congress also instructed the Commerce Department (NTIA) to collect very similar data, and instructed other federal agencies to collect different, relevant broadband-related data, in the 2008 Broadband Data Improvement Act ("BDIA").  

Both laws, essentially, seek the same thing--a static inventory of broadband availability in America.  The NOFA requires periodic updates, so "static" isn't an entirely fair characterization, but it's not that far away.  "Backward-looking" is probably a more accurate characterization.  The ultimate "purpose" of the map can be as obvious (and useful) as just letting policymakers know who still needs access to broadband service.  Another good use of the map/data is to provide feedback on whether policies are working.  More importantly, though, the mapping data can be even more helpful to broadband penetration and deployment if it helps to eliminate information gaps/inefficiencies that prevent forces of supply and demand from working as they should.  A broadband map that helped to facilitate this intermediation function would easily pay for the $350 million allocated for the map. 


Continue reading Broadband Mapping NOFA: "NOFA" Enough, But Not "BADFA" A First Try
April 8, 2009 2:25 AM

Broadband Map? Makes Me Want to Take a Nap . . . Instead, Let's Make It a Treasure Map!

It's been said that, "[a] movie scene depicting Chuck Norris losing a fight with Bruce Lee was the product of history's most expensive visual effect. When adjusted for inflation, the effect cost more than the Gross National Product of Paraguay."  If this is true, and I'm not saying it isn't, history's second most expensive visual effect might be the $350 million broadband map that the NTIA is charged with creating under the ARRA See p. 14.  In all the discussions of how to spend the broadband stimulus money, very little attention has been devoted to what is potentially "history's second most expensive visual effect."  I'm not saying the broadband map is destined to earn this title, but the NTIA and the FCC owe the broadband map some thoughtful, up-front attention--even before money starts to be distributed--in order to maximize the broadband stimulus grants.  However, it's easy for me to say the map deserves some serious attention, but the real question here is how do you make a map produce $350 million in value to American taxpayers?


Continue reading Broadband Map? Makes Me Want to Take a Nap . . . Instead, Let's Make It a Treasure Map!